PDA

View Full Version : i was offered Moulson and J Carter for Semin ?


aegluc
10-24-2011, 02:57 PM
M. Moulson and J Carter for Semin. Go for it or not ?
flubber
10-24-2011, 03:15 PM
M. Moulson and J Carter for Semin. Go for it or not ?

I believe Carter is due back soon and I would take Carter over Semin-- I have an aversion to Semin though as I have never ever drafted him-- Moulson is good additional compensation-- How deep is your league? or more to the point who you have to drop?


I would take Carter over Semin but given how Columbus and Washington are each scoring these days I could understand some hesitation, particularly over Carter's injury
aegluc
10-24-2011, 03:20 PM
I would drop either Burrows or Pronger.. I wouldnt mind playing with 1 less D for a while. We are 8 teams H2H points. im 1-1 after 2 weeks.

Kopitar,Towes, Burrows, Benn, Jagr, Gaborik, Ryan Nuggent Hopkins, Semin, Cammalleri, Shea Weber, Duncan Keith, Burns, Pronger, Hedberg, Niemi, Rinne
mbr311
10-24-2011, 03:23 PM
I would drop either Burrows or Pronger.. I wouldnt mind playing with 1 less D for a while. We are 8 teams H2H points. im 1-1 after 2 weeks.

Kopitar,Towes, Burrows, Benn, Jagr, Gaborik, Ryan Nuggent Hopkins, Semin, Cammalleri, Shea Weber, Duncan Keith, Burns, Pronger, Hedberg, Niemi, Rinne

Wow...I wouldn't drop either of those players and here's why - I like Moulson, he's a good player and he could get say 20 goals/40 assists...but I would take Burrows or Pronger over him ANY DAY OF THE WEEK. Just from the simple fact that you would have to drop Burrows or Pronger to get Moulson in this deal I wouldn't do it. If you are dead set on obtaining Carter then go ahead and offer Semin straight up for him. Do not include obtaining Moulson in the deal because it makes NO SENSE for you to get Moulson and drop a better player on your roster to get him. Does that make sense?
aegluc
10-24-2011, 03:25 PM
Yes it does make perfect sense. Im actually considering including Weber in the trade and get Pietrangelo. I have rinne and im nto so convinced on Nashville this season. Would that make sense? Weber and Semin for Carter and Pietrangelo ?
mbr311
10-24-2011, 03:26 PM
Well I love Pietrangelo personally I drafted him pretty high...what are your scoring categories though?
aegluc
10-24-2011, 03:27 PM
G 2
a 1
+/- 1
ppp 1
shg 1
gwg 1
sog 0.2
pim -0.5