Dynasty league trade proposal...D. Roy for D'Agostini/Pierre-Marc Bouchard..thoughts?

[sirmoz]

I've received the above trade proposal and I'm looking for some advice on whether this is a deal I should consider. Thanks.


Centers:
Evgeni Malkin, PIT, C
Anze Kopitar, LAK, C
Derek Roy, BUF, C
Shawn Horcoff, EDM, C
Saku Koivu, ANA, C
Alex Steen, STL, C
David Desharnais, MTL, C

Right Wingers:
Corey Perry, ANA, RW
Justin Williams, LAK, RW
Teddy Purcell, TB, RW
Brian Gionta, MTL, RW
Jamie Langenbrunner, STL, RW
Cal Clutterbuck, MIN, RW

Left Wingers:
Thomas Vanek, BUF, LW
Michael Cammalleri, MTL, LW
Chris Kunitz, PIT, LW
Milan Michalek, OTT, LW
Nikolai Kulemin, TOR, LW
Patrick Sharp, CHI, LW/C
Vernon Fiddler, DAL, LW

Defensemen:
Kris Letang, PIT, D
Duncan Keith, CHI, D
Joe Corvo, BOS, D
Kimmo Timmonen, PHI, D
Jason Demers, SJS, D
Zbynek Michalek, PIT, D
Jason Garrison, FLA, D

Goalies:
Tim Thomas, BOS, G
Semyon Varlamov, COL, G
Michael Neuvirth, WAS, G
Scott Clemmensen, FLA, G (IR)


Goombajohnny Prospect Roster:

Ethan Werek, PHX, C
Nathan Gerbe, BUF, W
Oscar Moller, LAK, C/RW
Brett Sonne, STL, LW
Dana Tyrell, TB, C/LW
Igor Makarov, CHI, RW
Nick Peterson, PIT, RW
Ben Hanowski, PIT, W
Nick Spaling, NSH, LW
Kaspars Daugavins, OTT, LW
Johan Ryno, DET, RW
Oskars Bartulis, PHI, D
Adam Larsson, NJ, D

[NightParade]

No Deal, Roy is the youngest of the three and the most talented. This isn't even close to a trade I'd make. (unless I was getting Roy)

[sirmoz]

Roy is actually the oldest of the 3, he's 28, D'Agostini is 25 and Bouchard is 27. Roy is about a 60 pt average per year, D'Agostini is 40-45 pt average and Bouchard is 40-50 pt average. I would think with the slight upgrade in age and the combined points of those 2 players that the deal would lean a little more that way.

[NightParade]

My bad, he is the oldest of the three, and D'Agostini makes it more appealing as three years younger. I apologize for my errors and my advice.

Thanks for the correction Sirmoz. I'm sure the op would have seen the error of my ways though :)

That makes it a tougher choice, but now I lwean towards taking the deal.

Edit: Wow, I need sleep, you are the op. . .

[mbr311]

Roy is actually the oldest of the 3, he's 28, D'Agostini is 25 and Bouchard is 27. Roy is about a 60 pt average per year, D'Agostini is 40-45 pt average and Bouchard is 40-50 pt average. I would think with the slight upgrade in age and the combined points of those 2 players that the deal would lean a little more that way.

Sounds to me like you answered your own question then didn't you? ;)

[sirmoz]

Yeah, I know, but I'm fairly new to this whole dynasty league thing, so I would want several different opinions and viewpoints and things I may not be taking into consideration.