Trade Advice Please

[dlumley]

I have been offered a couple trades that I could use some advice on but first here is my team. I am in a 16 player yahoo league (not head to heat).

C
Pavel Datsyuk
(Det - C,LW) Player Highlights
96% 23 36 11 15 18 137 232.30
C
Tomas Plekanec
(Mon - C) Player Highlights
44% 22 35 8 60 18 227 282.80
LW
Rick Nash
(Cls - LW,RW)
95% 32 34 2 34 14 305 319.00
LW
Johan Franzen
(Det - LW,RW) Player Highlights
87% 28 27 5 58 17 248 288.20
RW
Jaromir Jagr
(Phi - RW)
61% - - - - - - 0.00
RW
Teemu Selanne
(Anh - RW) Player Highlights
53% 31 49 6 49 34 213 340.70
D
Nicklas Lidstrom
(Det - D) Player Highlights
96% 16 46 -2 20 39 175 257.00
D
Alexander Edler
(Van - D) Player Highlights
74% 8 25 13 24 17 121 164.40
D
Ryan Suter
(Nsh - D) Player Highlights
71% 4 35 20 54 17 115 192.00
D
Ian White
(Det - D) Player Highlights
16% 4 22 3 26 6 138 133.20
BN
Brad Boyes
(Buf - C,RW)NA Player Highlights
35% 17 38 13 36 13 178 242.20
BN
Chris Kunitz
(Pit - LW)
15% 23 25 18 47 11 133 224.70
BN
Jay Bouwmeester
(Cgy - D)
14% 4 20 -2 44 8 121 128.40

G
Ilya Bryzgalov
(Phi - G) Player Highlights
95% 36 168 1957 7 381.40
BN
Martin Brodeur
(NJ - G)
69% 23 127 1186 6 214.20

The trades I have been offered are:

- I give up Alex Edler & Rick Nash for Corey Perry

- I give up Jarimor Jager for Mike Cammilerri

I am leaning towards no on both of them but I'd like to see some opinions.

[Mike]

The trades I have been offered are:

- I give up Alex Edler & Rick Nash for Corey Perry

- I give up Jarimor Jager for Mike Cammilerri

I would not make either of these trades.

I want to elaborate on the Perry offer: sometimes it's not whether or not the value of the trade is fair, rather it's whether or not you can replace a player lost in the deal. Here, I'm referring specifically to Edler.

[hovercraft]

yeah I would'nt do them either. Edler is definitely going to crack 50 points this year

[dlumley]

Thanks guys!

Any advice on what positions I need an upgrade in? Obviously every team has room for improvement but I don't think i am that hard off here.

[dlumley]

Right now I do not have a replacement for Edler if i were to make the deal. I was leaning towards no on that anyway. I'd get stuck in a position where I needed to play jay-bo as a starter or hope to get lucky off the waiver wire.

[Habs1]

I would trade Jagr for Cammalleri. I hate being the guy in the league that has "the old man". I like having young studs on my team, not guys looking to retire after the season, but thats just me I guess.

[Rocketman9]

I would also do the Jagr for Cammy. I am a habs fan though so I could be biased.

[Wings9798]

I'll jump on the Jagr for Cammy deal too. Short term Jagr may start well to prove himself, but come December I think Cammy has more upside for the long haul.

[Habs1]

I would also do the Jagr for Cammy. I am a habs fan though so I could be biased.

I (obviously) have a pro Montreal bias too. But to be honest, if Jagr was on the Habs too, I would still trade him for Cammy.

[SirJesto]

I wouldn't be so quick to jettison Yammy yaggy quite yet....