Keeper league (Keep top 5)
I have Crosby and Semin. Should I accept?
What kind of scoring system do you have?
I think it's default Yahoo.
G, A, PPP, GWG, +/-, PIM
One more question... in each case (trade or no trade) who would you keep as your top 5?
Would be keep both pairs of players probably
Ovi, Lundquist, Duchene would be the 3 other ones I'd most likely keep
It may hurt a little this year, but I'd keep Crosby/Semin.
As I've said before, my tiebreakers in tough keeper decisions like this is usually age, and in this case, without looking at their ages, I would say that Crosby and Semin combined are younger, so keep them.
Ouch this is one of those trades that's awfully hard to pass up given the short term results would heavily favor you. But as it's a keeper league I don't know if I could ever part with Crosby.
The other tough thing in my mind is he said he'd keep Ovi, Lundy and Duchene. The fact that he's gonna keep Duchene worries me in terms of depth..also keeping crosby and semin from what I gather. Is that really better than Ovi, Lundy, sedin, Getzlaf and Duchene? And I say that only be ause I don't think Semin is up there with either Getzlaf or sedin. So the tough thing is to me that when you combine both players for keeper purposes I personally like the combo of sedin and Getzlaf over crosby and semin. Can you pull off say Semin straight up for Getzlaf? That would be the best case scenario for you IMO
Who are your goalie and why aren't you keeping one of them?Originally Posted by the_shizzle1
Mike - he actually said he would be keeping Lundy IIRC. However I don't get keeping Duchene he's got to have a better option than that I'd think.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote