So,
I was just offered a trade in a keeper league.
I was offered Teddy Purcell and Drew Doughty + 14th round pick
for
Artem Anisimov and Justin Schultz + 13th round pick
This is a 12 team keeper league and we keep10 year to year
Stats are: G, A, P, +/-, PIM, PPP, SHP, GWG, SOG
Wondering if I should even consider this, I love Schultz's potential, love Doughty but LA has problems scoring. Should I:
1. Take the offer
2. Counter for more
3. Reject and keep Schultz
Rocketman
LWL Non-Keeper - Apex Predators - Finished 5th
Death for Seth- LWL FHL Keeper- Finished 9th
G, A, +/-, PIM, PPP, SHP, FOW, HIT, BLK, W, GAA, SV, SV%, SO
C - S. Crosby, J. Benn (LW), J. Spezza
Wingers- J. Iginla, J. Carter (C), I. Kovalchuck
D - Z. Chara, D. Boyle, D. Girardi
G - S. Bobrovsky, E. Nabokov, V. Fasth
I love the upside Schultz has. I wouldn't be able to part with him myself right now.
Finished 1st
12 Team Yahoo Rotisserie Standard Scoring
C - Kopitar, Getzlaf
LW - Hall, Moulson
RW - Malkin (C), Iginla
D - Weber, Phaneuf, Visnovsky, Souray
G - Quick, Niemi, Anderson
Bench - Pominville (Rw), Muzzin (D)
Take a shot with a counter, if not reject.
His Roster is:Originally Posted by hookhoax
I didn't included goalies because I have no interest in them
Mikael Granlund
Eric Staal
Jordan Staal
Milan Lucic
Marian Gaborik
Teddy Purcell
Zack Kassian
Alexander Edler
Drew Doughty
Michael Del Zotto
Kimmo Timonen
Cody Hodgson
Taylor Hall
Ryan Callahan
Jamie Benn
Any thoughts who I should counter as a main piece for Schultz? Trying to gauge value
Rocketman
LWL Non-Keeper - Apex Predators - Finished 5th
Death for Seth- LWL FHL Keeper- Finished 9th
G, A, +/-, PIM, PPP, SHP, FOW, HIT, BLK, W, GAA, SV, SV%, SO
C - S. Crosby, J. Benn (LW), J. Spezza
Wingers- J. Iginla, J. Carter (C), I. Kovalchuck
D - Z. Chara, D. Boyle, D. Girardi
G - S. Bobrovsky, E. Nabokov, V. Fasth
My $0.02: I'm in two pools where I've been building towards success with prospects. Moderate success so far. I find it hard to cut bait on prospects sometimes.
Doughty + Purcell give you a greater chance to win now and in next couple years. Schultz has great upside, with a talented team... hard to trade him I bet.
I'd try to upgrade my pick, but otherwise I'm happy making that deal.
Franchise Keeper
C-Tavares, Giroux, Hodgson
LW-Neal, Sedin, McDonald
RW-Simmonds, Voracek, Stewart
D-Karlsson, Subban, Edler, Green
G-Bryzgalov, Niemi
BN-M. Koivu, Clowe, Varlamov, Neuvirth, Bernier
LWL Keeper
C-Tavares, Weiss, Stepan
LW-Sedin, Vanek, Eriksson
RW-Seguin, Kane, St Louis
D-Doughty, Garrison, OEL, Carlson
G-Schneider, Smith
BN-Ennis, Clarkson, Purcell, Granlund, Pavelec
Difficult, very difficult.
I think you're right in looking at Schultz' potential given that's it's a scoring league (practically a points league if you ignore PIMs) as I think he'll outperform Doughty most seasons going forward (maybe even this one seeing as Doughty has actually scored less each year). Purcell is also on the up and should easily outperform Anisimov going forward; I'd rate Purcell as 55+ points with Anisimov 45+ on current projections but obviously dropping a round in the draft could hurt.
I would take this trade only under a couple of conditions:
1) You are looking at making a real push at winning the league this year or next
2) You think Doughty will get back to his 09/10 form this year or next
3) You are struggling with keepers so much that Anisimov is comfortably in your 10 keeper list
East Pond Dwellers - LWL Non-Keeper
C - Tavares, Krejci, Cervenka, Backes (RW), Filppula (LW)
LW - Landeskog, Hall, Filppula (C), Eriksson (RW), Michalek (RW)
RW - Parenteau, Tarasenko, Backes (C), Eriksson (LW), Michalek (LW)
D - Shattenkirk, Timonen, Yandle, Hedman, Hamonic
G - Quick, Backstrom, Vokoun, Fasth
I agree. As long as your league does not favor hits and blocked shot type dmen and favors offensive types like Schultz, I'd keep Schultz-- just think of that Powerplay in 2 years time... IMO Schultz> Doughty which may seem ridiculous after 3 games but I have watched all 3 Oiler games and this kid is for real offensively. There was areson there was so my much buzz around him this offseason.
Oppositions have learned to key on Doughty on the PP and I see his offensive upside being blunted by Sutter's coaching style.
The Purcell/Anisimov side of things would not play into my decision at all. Keep Schultz and enjoy the ride for many years to come.
Last edited by jal179; 01-25-2013 at 10:40 PM.
12 team nk roto G,A,+/-,PPP,SHP,Hits,GWG, SOG,W,L,GAA,SV%,SO
C- Toews, Datsyuk
RW- Eberle, Gaborik
LW- JStaal, Doan
F- MKoivu
D- Karlsson, JSchultz, Girardi
U- ZKassian
G- Lundqvist, MSmith, Varlamov, Neuvirth
Bench- DBrown, Hodgson
9 team nk roto G,A,+/-,PPP,SHP,Hits,GWG,W,GAA,SV%,SO
C- Tavares, HSedin
LW- DSedin, JStaal
RW- P Sharp, Callahan
F- MKoivu
D- Edler, RSuter, Seabrook
G- Lundquist, Halak, Lehtonen
U- Kunitz
B- Oshie, Tarasenko, Kronwall
Maybe look again. Purcell went 24G 41A last year, and even more importantly popped 19 PPP's. True, he's not big on physical numbers like hits & blocks, but he contributes a lot in scoring categories, and he's off to a decent start again. Anisimov on the other hand, scored 34 points last year, but he's not a NYR any more - he's in the nether reaches of Columbus. Purcell is a significant scoring upgrade right now vis-a-vis Anisimov.
"Hey hey, my my, rock and roll can never die."
I agree with you cowtown, but i rejected anyway.
I also dropped Anismov for Kyle Turris.
Last edited by Rocketman9; 01-26-2013 at 01:29 PM.
Rocketman
LWL Non-Keeper - Apex Predators - Finished 5th
Death for Seth- LWL FHL Keeper- Finished 9th
G, A, +/-, PIM, PPP, SHP, FOW, HIT, BLK, W, GAA, SV, SV%, SO
C - S. Crosby, J. Benn (LW), J. Spezza
Wingers- J. Iginla, J. Carter (C), I. Kovalchuck
D - Z. Chara, D. Boyle, D. Girardi
G - S. Bobrovsky, E. Nabokov, V. Fasth
Man....just keep Schultz, imo
[espn 12 team h2h] The Bastard Blues[ G, A, +/-, GWG, PIM, FOW, HAT, HIT, BLK, PPP, SHG, D POINT+1....retarded....][SV, SO, W, OTL]
C-E.Staal(lw)- Duchene(lw)-Bozak
LW- Marleau-D.Brown(rw)
RW-St.Louis-Jagr-Simmonds(lw)-Iginla-Horton
D-Weber-M.Fraser(tor)- Markov-Ju.Schultz-Subban-Beauchemin-Burns(rw)-Pitkanen
G-Rinne-Vokoun-Schneider
IR-Kesler
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote