Franzen and P. Bergeron for Skinner

[toesave]

I proposed the following: My Franzen and P. Bergeron for his Jeff Skinner.

16 team 4 division yahoo H2H Cats: G A +/- PIM PPP GWG W GAA SV% SO

My roster:
C: GETZLAF, P. BERGERON, BENN (C,LW)
LW: NASH(LW,RW) FRANZEN (LW,RW)
RW: LUPUL (LW,RW) SIMMONDS, C. STEWART
D: BOYLE, EDLER
G: MILLER, SCHNEIDER

His roster:
C: SKINNER (C,RW) BOYES (C,RW)
LW: SEMIN (LW,RW) FLEISCHMANN
RW: POMINVILLE, VORACEK, CLARKSON
D: DOUGHTY, EHRHOFF, CAMPBELL
G: LUNDQVIST, WARD

If you were in his shoes, would you accept?

[shankm]

Yeah I would. Franzen doing well so far, even though the Wings haven’t and Boston turning it around lately. Boyes and Semin are performing nowhere near their potential, Voracek not standing out. If I were him, I would.

[amarius87]

I definetly would. I think youre losing valuable points, i see it as bergeron for skinner. bergeron has stepped up his game, recently and i think he will probably finish with about the same points as skinner, also if plus minus is a stat, bergeron by end of season will be ahead most likely. Also franzen is a beast on the pp and plays with datsuk and should only improve on his career best, as long he stays healty. Imo i wouldnt do this trade.

[Flames89Champs]

If this is a keeper league.. Skinner is a great addition.. and Bergeron has had injury problems in the past. Franzen is streaky.. and could be the deal breaker either way... so I don't think I would accept.

But if it isn't a keeper league.. then ya I would accept the trade because with the way Bergeron is playing lately.. like someone said.. that's an even up trade, with an added bonus of Franzen.

[shankm]

I definetly would. I think youre losing valuable points, i see it as bergeron for skinner. bergeron has stepped up his game, recently and i think he will probably finish with about the same points as skinner, also if plus minus is a stat, bergeron by end of season will be ahead most likely. Also franzen is a beast on the pp and plays with datsuk and should only improve on his career best, as long he stays healty. Imo i wouldnt do this trade.

Yeah. If I were him, I’d do it. If I were you, I wouldn’t. Or instead of trying to get Skinner, I’d try to get Lundqvist or Ward.