Khabibulin for Enroth?

[Spacemoose]

Is it worth dropping Khabbi for Enroth? Pool takes into account wins, save %, GAA and shutouts. I'm leaning towards yes, keeping in mind i have marty and thomas as my main 2... any thoughts?

[mbr311]

How many goalies can you carry?

Also are you thinking about this more seriously be ause of what happened to Khabby tonight or because you truly believe Enroth is the better of the two? I will point out one last thing: when Miller comes back he will get the #1 job back. If you drop Khabby you'll also probably never see him again. If you could carry 4 goalies that obviously would be the most ideal situation. Just my .01 as always

[Spacemoose]

How many goalies can you carry?

Also are you thinking about this more seriously be ause of what happened to Khabby tonight or because you truly believe Enroth is the better of the two? I will point out one last thing: when Miller comes back he will get the #1 job back. If you drop Khabby you'll also probably never see him again. If you could carry 4 goalies that obviously would be the most ideal situation. Just my .01 as always

I can carry 4, but I don't see that as a viable option... I give up way too much in games played from my forwards doing that with not enough of an upside. I'm barely willing to carry 3. I thought of this before seeing what happened to khabbi tonight. My plan was to rotate my 3rd goalie position in and out using hot goalies..

I guess I'm wondering if people feel he's for real long term, or should I be more willing to rotate that position out.

[mbr311]

But goalie categories make up 4/11ths of your score, I don't think you're giving ANYTHING up by carrying at least 3. No 3 players in any format will have a bigger impact on your score. If you can carry 3 #1s I would do it in a second without any hesitation..which is why I'm suggesting keeping either Khabby or Enroth and not rotating that 3rd spot. I understand your roster size is much smaller than mine so your needs are a bit different, but it still comes back to the fact that goalie categories are extremely important under your format and if you can carry 3 top #1s like you are in a position to, and get a lock down on the goalie categories week in, week out, I mean you are WAAAAY ahead of the pack.

[Spacemoose]

But goalie categories make up 4/11ths of your score, I don't think you're giving ANYTHING up by carrying at least 3. No 3 players in any format will have a bigger impact on your score. If you can carry 3 #1s I would do it in a second without any hesitation..which is why I'm suggesting keeping either Khabby or Enroth and not rotating that 3rd spot. I understand your roster size is much smaller than mine so your needs are a bit different, but it still comes back to the fact that goalie categories are extremely important under your format and if you can carry 3 top #1s like you are in a position to, and get a lock down on the goalie categories week in, week out, I mean you are WAAAAY ahead of the pack.

The more I think of it, the more I think I may want to give it a try.. Although not this week, as due to an unfortunate game matchup my opponant has an extra 8 skater games on me this week.. Who would you guys rather have (out of these FA goalies)

Mike Smith, Craig Anderson, Brian Elliot, Theodore, Pavalec, Backstrom, Roloson, Harding or Varlamov. Various other starters like mason and halak are available too but there are obviously better options...

[NightParade]

8 team league, as much as I think Khabi will have a solid season you're going to have good pickups all year, it doesn't hurt to roll the dice. If your league was a bit deeper I'd say no, but under the circumstances it might be worth a shot.